"Alternative Treatments"
Email this topic to a friend
Printer-friendly version of this topic
Archived thread - Read only 
Previous Topic | Next Topic 
Home Conferences Support (new) (Public)
Original message

msmom Click to EMail msmomClick to check IP address of the poster Apr-13-00, 07:28 AM (CST)
"Alternative Treatments"
This is almost a duplicate of a message that I posted on another forum. I apologize if I'm boring some of you, but there's been enough talk about this over here that I think it's relevant. I've been seeing a lot of discussion of alternative treatments for herpes recently, and I'd like to put my two cents in on that subject in general.

First, let me say that I'm not opposed to alternative health care. I had an experimental procedure when I injured my back a few years ago and I today I am much more physically capable that people who had the standard surgery. My daughter's initial treatment for genital herpes was a bit non-standard as well, and her results were good. Straying from the beaten path can be a good thing.

There are many folk therapies and treatment options that may help *you* but will never be approved by the AMA or the FDA for one reason or another - No profit in it so it gets no push, doesn't work for everyone, too hard to do trials on, and so on and so on. There is also a lot of snake oil out there, some of which will just drain your wallet and some of which can actually hurt you.

If you plan to pursue alternate treatments, you are essentially becoming your own primary care provider. This makes sense in a way - who cares more about your health than you do? But it does mean you need to gain the knowledge to do a good job of it. You need to learn about the disorder you want to treat, what causes it, what makes symptoms appear, how the body reacts to it over time. You need to understand how current standard treatments work and what the side effects are. You also need to research the operation and potential side effects of the alternatives you are considering. Do this *independently* - don't rely on literature or explanations provided by whoever is recommending the treatment.

If you can, find a physician who will work with you. I've found that D.O.'s (osteopaths), sports physicians, doctors with small family practices and those who emphasize holistic care are your best bets for finding an open mind.

A couple of things in particular to beware of: some of the substances used in alternative treatments are not manufactured for human use. This means they are not subject to the same standards of purity that your everyday food and drugs are. Contaminants in these substances can be very dangerous - even fatal.

If a product claims that it is "FDA registered" or something of that nature, be sure you understand what that means. Items that the FDA classifies as nutritional supplements are not closely regulated - essentially the FDA will allow them to be sold as long as they follow labeling rules and the substance does not appear to be immediately toxic when consumed. Sometimes, this is not much help - remember fen-Phen?

Also, be sure you understand the natural process of your condition over time. A really great way to generate long term sales is to take credit for what nature way going to do anyway. For example, hsv symptoms tend to be most severe in the first 24 months or so post-infection, so if I claim that a product will control herpes but takes two years, people can get the impression that the product is helping, when in reality the symptoms would have decreased on their own.

Another thing: remember that change in general can provide temporary improvement. For example, have you noticed that a new shampoo works better the first time to two you use it, even if you don't like it in the long run? Same thing can apply to treatments - changing your vitamins or whatever sometimes makes you feel better for a bit just because of the change.

Anyway, pursue alternate treatments if you like, but do it with your eyes open, and not in blind desperate hope of a cure.

Oh, and one more thing: if you try an alternative treatment, a supplement or a diet, and it works for you, by all means, tell us about your experience. But please, don't be so arrogant as to start pushing that treatment down other people's throats or set yourself up as an "on-line physician", making official-sounding recommendations and dispensing advice. Doctors, chiropractors and other health care providers are *extremely cautious* about dispensing blanket advice to people that they haven't met and examined, and there is a good reason for this. A program that worked perfectly *for you* could be damaging to another person due to allergies, immune system response, age, other health conditions or any number of variables. Remember that the essence of alternative treatment is self care, and that means allowing people to make up their own minds.

My opinions, still free.


 Table of contents

Alternative Treatments Please pro..., will, Apr-13-00, (1)
Here's my feedback, Will, M'sMom, Apr-13-00, (2)
Good point, Mom, lisx, Apr-13-00, (3)

Lobby | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic
Messages in this topic

will Click to EMail willClick to check IP address of the poster Apr-13-00, 09:30 AM (CST)
1. " Alternative Treatments Please provide feed back"
I thank you for your post, I feel like your our mom looking over us.

please everyone check this out and let me know what you think



M'sMom Click to EMail M'sMomClick to check IP address of the poster Apr-13-00, 09:51 AM (CST)
2. "Here's my feedback, Will"
I looked into this guy a few months ago, and I'm not real impressed. I can't find any real description of his methods or discussion by professionals OR patients. All the web refs I find to this program are just blurbs pointing to his site. I can't find reference to his graduation from medical school - and I asked a friend in med school in Mexico to check. As far as I can find he hasn't published any papers or applied for any patents.

There are several possible reasons that I can think of for this:

He wants to prevent others from leveraging his work, which strikes me as pretty unprofessional for a healer.

He is disconnected with the larger world of health care. This could be good or bad.

It could all be snake oil.

Two other comments:

The general description of his method seems to have a bit in common with the work being done by Antigenics. You can check them out at http://www.antigenics.com/ or read their patents from the US Patent Office. My take on their work was that while their techniques may very well be applicable to hsv, that's not the direction their research is really pushing.

I would never go to Mexico for medical services of any kind - I've had a couple of friends have really bad experiences.

Keep rattling the cages, Will.



lisx Click to EMail lisxClick to check IP address of the poster Apr-13-00, 07:00 PM (CST)
3. "Good point, Mom"
Good point and well made. I have been thinking along the same lines myself the past few days. I fully believe that there are some alternative therapies that are very helpful for a variety of complaints, and I often take my children to see a registered natural therapist if they are sick and not responding to our medical doctor's treatment.

I always remember my father saying that if something seems to good to be true, then it probably is. There is no cure for herpes. If someone is claiming they can cure your virus, they are hanging you for a sucker with the sole aim of parting you from your money.

I know that it can be so uplifting in the early months after diagnosis to really believe that you have come across something that will make you well, and stop you from feeling as though your life is over. But we mustn't be sucked in. A cure for herpes, should one ever exist, will be all over the news and not hiding on some tatty little web page maintained by Charlatains.

I am not a cynic. I believe that many of us need to cure the social and emotional disease that herpes can foist upon us. It is not as bad as it seems. We are all doing really well. Pats on the back all round.

Love lisx



Lobby | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic












Questions or problems regarding this bulletin board should be directed to Webmaster
1997-1999 by DCScripts. All rights reserved.